a critical analysis of modarresi tabatabayi’s views in his work “maktab dar faraayande takaamol” on the shi'i traditions (ahadith)

regarding the formative period of shi'i islam and shi'i intellectual history, seyyed hosein modarresi tabatabayi in his work (“maktab dar farayande takamol”) proposed a plan according to which he claimed that some of the shi'i traditions (ahadith) which are not consistent with his plan, are fictitious. examining the sufficiency and correctness of his arguments, we can classify his claims on the shi'i traditions (ahadith) to three groups: -the cases about which his arguments seems not to be sufficient. -the cases about which his arguments seems not to be correct. -the cases about which he has some claim without any reason.  so, in all the cases, it cannot be shown that these traditions (ahadith) are fictitious.